Franck & Martin’s Piano Quintets

July 2023
The Armida Quartett, joined by the pianist Martin Klett, delivers a compelling performance of Franck and Martin’s Piano Quintets in this captivating release by CAvi-music. The recording showcases the distinct approaches of the two composers to the piano quintet medium, with Franck placing the piano at the forefront and Martin reserving it for a unique role.

Franck’s 1879 composition presents a rich tapestry of melodies, where the piano takes on a prominent and leading role. The performers embrace Franck’s intricate melodies, weaving them into a cohesive and emotionally charged narrative. The Armida Quartett and Martin Klett exhibit a remarkable ability to convey the nuances of Franck’s dynamic range, effortlessly navigating from the most delicate pianissimos to thundering fortissimos. Throughout the work, their synergy and interpretive depth create a harmonious balance, drawing the listener into Franck’s intricate tonal exploration.

In contrast, Martin’s 1919 Piano Quintet displays a more fragmented and contrapuntal approach to composition. The 29-year-old composer’s skill in intertwining brief musical ideas is evident, although he diverges from Franck’s penchant for building long, sweeping melodies. This divergence presents a challenge that the performers meet with finesse, embracing the intricacies of Martin’s composition. The musicians’ trust in the composer’s markings allows the work’s complexity to shine, with the only exception being a minor unmarked accelerando in the final bars of the Franck piece.

One of the intriguing commonalities between Franck and Martin lies in their playful treatment of tonality. Franck’s daring shifts between D flat major and A minor are matched by Martin’s even bolder tonal explorations. The note-writer’s insight into Martin’s avant-garde inclinations adds depth to the analysis, noting that despite brief forays into 12-note serialism, tonality remains the guiding force.

The Armida Quartett and Martin Klett excel in their execution, showcasing a remarkable range of dynamics that spans from the most delicate lyricism to awe-inspiring grandeur. Their collective virtuosity is harnessed masterfully, allowing the performers to traverse the demanding terrain of both Franck and Martin’s works. The ensemble’s ability to maintain a well-balanced interplay between instruments contributes to the recording’s overall coherence.

While the review does not dwell on minor imperfections, the unmarked accelerando in the Franck’s closing bars is a forgivable exception. In light of the exceptional performances throughout, this minor deviation seems inconsequential.

Armida Quartett and Martin Klett’s  commitment to embracing the distinct nuances of each work, along with their impeccable technical prowess, results in a recording that invites listeners to delve into the intricate musical landscapes crafted by Franck and Martin. This release is a testament to the musicians’ artistry and dedication, making it a valuable addition to any classical music collection.