Chopin by Ivo Pogorelich

February 2022
Ivo Pogorelich’s “Chopin” marks a daring return to the spotlight, presenting a collection of Chopin’s works that challenges conventions and pushes the boundaries of interpretation. As a provocateur of the piano world, Pogorelich is no stranger to controversy, and this album continues that legacy with more concentrated and purposeful fervor.

The opening tracks feature Pogorelich’s signature sustained approach, notably in the Chopin C minor and E major Nocturnes. Unusually protracted, these performances captivate the listener with their intense emotional resonance. The centerpiece of the album, the F minor Fantasy, is a tour de force, clocking in at a staggering 16 minutes longer than the average rendition. Pogorelich’s transformation of the Lento sostenuto section into a profound largo is a masterstroke, evoking a sense of timelessness and profound introspection. However, some might find his restrained accelerations and dry legato phrases to be an acquired taste.

The B minor Sonata showcases Pogorelich’s unorthodox yet fascinating approach. The first movement surprises with extreme metrical leeway and microscopic attention to detail. While some might raise an eyebrow at his gargantuan ritardando before the development section, it serves to illuminate the intricate counterpoint and build a gripping harmonic tension. The Scherzo’s outer sections maintain a nimble and supple quality, but the Trio seems to wander indefinitely, stretching the limits of its expressiveness.

In the Largo, Pogorelich paints an intimate portrait that transforms into a larger-than-life canvas, captivating the listener with its emotional depth. However, the finale falls short, lacking the spark seen in Pogorelich’s earlier video recording from the Racconigi Castle (DG). While undeniably individualistic, this interpretation feels cluttered with excessive voicings and phrasings, diminishing its overall impact.

Unfortunately, technical issues from his first Sony release still linger, with moments of sonic stridency and harshness in the louder passages. These detract from the otherwise mesmerizing performances, leaving some listeners longing for a cleaner and more polished sound.

“Chopin” is a bold and audacious album that showcases the pianist’s willingness to challenge conventions and take risks with his interpretations. While some moments might not resonate with everyone, there is no denying the sheer passion and intensity that Pogorelich brings to these performances. His ability to evoke emotions and draw the listener into Chopin’s world is undeniable, making this album a must-listen for those seeking fresh and unconventional perspectives on the beloved composer’s music.