Barber · Bruch

Barber · Bruch

Emotional Mastery: Barber • Bruch Violin Concertos by Esther Yoo and Royal Philharmonic Orchestra

February 2023
From the very first notes of Bruch’s Violin Concerto No. 1 in G minor, Esther Yoo weaves a spellbinding performance, infusing well-known phrases with yearning intensity and introspective awe. Vasily Petrenko’s masterful direction delicately balances the orchestra, allowing Yoo’s artistry to shine through effortlessly.

Esther Yoo’s interpretation of Bruch’s Violin Concerto No. 1 in G minor immediately captures the listener’s attention with her yearning intensity and introspective awe in the opening recitativos. Petrenko’s handling of the orchestra strikes a delicate balance, skillfully dialing down the cello and bass pizzicatos to create a true piano un poco marcato. Comparisons with other renowned recordings reveal the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra’s finesse, as they embrace the ominous descending minor thirds with controlled power rather than full-throttle forte, setting this rendition apart.

Yoo’s emotional artistry shines through in the slow movement, where she delicately floats the aching phrases with moving tendresse, inviting the listener into a world of half-whispered correspondences. In contrast, other interpretations like Isaac Stern’s display pulsating longing, creating a different but equally captivating experience. In the Adagio appassionato, Yoo brings out a heart-warming radiance, giving new life to this lesser-known gem, and outshining some previous renditions.

Moving on to the Barber Concerto, Yoo’s poetic resourcefulness and thoughtfulness add a fresh perspective, making the work feel more emotionally wide-ranging. While Stern’s rendition is overwhelmingly charismatic, Yoo’s interpretation provides a unique and captivating listening experience. The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra complements her beautifully, displaying glowing finesse, suppleness, and nimble virtuosity in the finale.

The album closes with Yoo’s spirited and indulgent performance in Vieuxtemps’ Variations on Yankee Doodle, where she confidently embraces portamentos and injects her signature flair. While Yoo excels in this piece, it’s worth noting that Itzhak Perlman’s rendition with Samuel Sanders remains a pinnacle of excitement and energy.

In summary, Barber • Bruch: Violin Concertos is a compelling recording that showcases Esther Yoo’s exceptional skills as a violinist, and the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra’s finesse under the baton of Vasily Petrenko. This album is a must-listen for both classical music enthusiasts and those looking to explore these timeless concertos with a fresh perspective.

Schubert – Allegretto D.915

Schubert – Allegretto D.915

Eric Lu’s Artistry Shines in ‘Schubert’

January 2023
Eric Lu’s rendition of Schubert’s piano compositions on his album “Schubert” reveals his virtuosic prowess and profound comprehension of the composer’s emotional depth. Lu’s expertise is evident from the very outset in Schubert’s Sonata D959. He expertly sculpts each phrase, extracting the intricate nuances and complexities of the music. His performance encapsulates Schubert’s introspective and poignant style, immersing the audience in a realm of profound sentiments.

An apex of Lu’s execution lies within the Andantino, where he infuses a chorale-like quality into the music. The depth of his expression is utterly captivating, and the tragic allure he bestows upon this movement is deeply affecting. Lu delves beneath the surface, unearthing the core of the music to convey an intense sense of sorrow and longing.

The album also features Schubert’s Sonata in A minor, composed in 1823. Lu’s decision to pair it with the Sonata D959 provides a fascinating juxtaposition, enabling listeners to traverse Schubert’s evolving compositional style. In the Sonata in A minor, Lu demonstrates his virtuosity and technical finesse, navigating the intricate passages with precision while maintaining a sense of musicality and lyricism.

Lu’s inclusion of the Allegretto in C minor (D915) between the two sonatas serves as an interlude, showcasing his ability to capture the essence of a miniature gem with clarity and grace.

Throughout the album, Lu adeptly navigates the emotional trajectory intrinsic to Schubert’s music. He adeptly traverses the emotional contours of the compositions, underscoring the dichotomy between light and darkness, joy and sorrow. Particularly noteworthy is his interpretation of the Rondo in Sonata D959, where he captures the unexpected introspection that lends depth to the movement.

In summation, Eric Lu’s “Schubert” offers an insightful exploration of Franz Schubert’s piano compositions. Lu’s profound sensitivity and technical brilliance breathe new life into these compositions, allowing audiences to experience the full spectrum of Schubert’s emotions. This album highlights Eric Lu’s stature among today’s preeminent Schubert interpreters and is essential listening for those seeking an immersive and emotionally resonant musical encounter.

Guitar Favourites

Guitar Favourites

Discovering Guitar Gems: Xuefei Yang’s Alluring Compilation

January 2023
Xuefei Yang’s latest offering, “Guitar Favourites,” is a captivating musical voyage that showcases her virtuosity and artistry as she delves into a rich array of guitar compositions from around the globe. Released under Decca, this album encapsulates the versatility and technical prowess that have become synonymous with Yang’s name.

Notably, Yang infuses her personal touch into every note, imbuing each piece with a distinct energy and interpretation. The album spans an impressive range, including works by renowned composers such as Barrios Mangoré, Sor, Albéniz, Lauro, Rodrigo, Tárrega, Villa-Lobos, John Williams, and her own composition, “Xinjang Fantasy,” which pays homage to the musical heritage of China’s Xinjiang region.

Yang’s technical precision and command over her instrument are undeniable, setting a high bar for her contemporaries. Her meticulous articulation and unwavering musical intention shine through, creating a spellbinding listening experience. While her mastery of technique is evident, it’s Yang’s emotive connection to the music that truly captivates the audience. Her performance of Tárrega’s “Recuerdos de la Alhambra” stands out, as she skillfully employs rubato to infuse the piece with an organic ebb and flow, evoking a sense of nostalgia and longing.

One intriguing aspect of this album is Yang’s decision to switch between two different guitars, each contributing a unique timbral quality to the recordings. Although this choice may occasionally create a subtle discontinuity, it offers a glimpse into Yang’s versatility and ability to adapt her playing style to different instruments. Her affinity for the lighter, brighter tones of her Greg Smallman guitar is palpable, lending an extra layer of authenticity to the performances where it is featured.

Xuefei Yang’s nuanced interpretations breathe new life into beloved classics and offer fresh perspectives on familiar compositions. Whether it’s the delicate harmonies of Barrios Mangoré’s “La Catedral,” the playful variations of Sor’s “Variations on a Theme by Mozart,” or the evocative allure of Rodrigo’s works, Yang proves to be a trustworthy guide through the diverse landscapes of guitar music.

In “Guitar Favourites,” Xuefei Yang proves herself to be a remarkable talent, capturing the essence of each composition while adding her own distinctive touch. Her unwavering commitment to both technical excellence and emotional expression solidifies her reputation as a true maestro of the classical guitar.

Daniil Trifonov

Daniil Trifonov

The Pianistic Virtuoso

Top Classical, January 2023
In the realm of classical music, there are virtuosos, and then there is Daniil Trifonov. Born in Nizhny Novgorod, Russia, in 1991, Trifonov’s rise to prominence as one of the world’s most exceptional pianists has been nothing short of spectacular. His journey through the world of classical music is a testament to his extraordinary talent, dedication, and unwavering passion for the piano.

From a young age, it was evident that Daniil Trifonov possessed a unique gift for music. His piano journey began early, and he quickly distinguished himself as a prodigious talent. Trifonov’s musical education took him to Moscow, where he studied at the Gnessin School of Music before continuing his training at the Cleveland Institute of Music in the United States.

Trifonov’s true breakthrough moment came in 2011 when he captured the Gold Medal at the prestigious Tchaikovsky International Piano Competition. This victory catapulted him into the international spotlight, and he has since become one of the most sought-after pianists on the global stage. His performance at the competition was marked not only by technical brilliance but also by a deep emotional connection to the music—a hallmark of his artistry that continues to captivate audiences worldwide.

One of Trifonov’s distinguishing features as a pianist is his ability to convey a profound range of emotions through his music. His interpretations are characterized by their sensitivity, depth, and an innate understanding of the composers’ intentions. Whether he is performing the fiery compositions of Rachmaninoff, the lyrical works of Chopin, or the complex pieces of Prokofiev, Trifonov’s performances are a mesmerizing journey into the heart of the music.

Daniil Trifonov’s recording career has been equally remarkable. He has released numerous albums, each receiving critical acclaim and further solidifying his status as a pianistic luminary. His interpretations of Rachmaninoff’s piano concertos have been particularly celebrated, capturing the essence of these monumental works with both technical brilliance and emotional depth.

Trifonov’s artistry is not limited to the recording studio; he is also a captivating live performer. His recitals and orchestral appearances around the world consistently leave audiences in awe. His virtuosic command of the piano, coupled with his ability to convey the most delicate nuances, makes each of his performances a transcendent experience.

Beyond the solo piano repertoire, Daniil Trifonov has collaborated with some of the world’s finest orchestras and conductors. His performances of Tchaikovsky, Beethoven, and Shostakovich concertos have been lauded for their electrifying energy and musical insight. He has graced the stages of prestigious venues, including Carnegie Hall, the Royal Albert Hall, and the Berlin Philharmonie, leaving an indelible mark on every audience he encounters.

In addition to his exceptional playing, Trifonov is known for his deep intellectual engagement with music. He has explored the works of various composers, delving into their lives and musical philosophies. This scholarly approach enriches his interpretations and provides audiences with a profound connection to the music.

As a pianist, Daniil Trifonov possesses a rare ability to transcend technical virtuosity and connect with listeners on a profound emotional level. His performances are characterized by their passion, precision, and unparalleled musicianship. Each note he plays is a testament to his lifelong dedication to his craft.

In recognition of his outstanding contributions to the world of classical music, Daniil Trifonov has received numerous awards and honors. His artistry continues to evolve, leaving an indelible mark on the world of classical piano.

Daniil Trifonov’s journey to excellence is a testament to the enduring power of music and the profound impact it can have on the human soul. As he continues to dazzle audiences around the globe with his extraordinary talent and boundless passion, the world eagerly anticipates the next chapters in the remarkable musical odyssey of Daniil Trifonov.

Christian Li

Christian Li

A young prodigy in the Wolrd of Classical Music

Top Classical, January 2023
In the world of classical music, prodigies are a rare and remarkable phenomenon. They emerge like shooting stars, capturing the hearts and minds of audiences with their extraordinary talent. Christian Li, a young violinist born in Melbourne in 2007, is one such prodigy whose journey through the world of classical music has been nothing short of extraordinary.

At the tender age of five, Christian Li first picked up a violin, setting in motion a musical journey that would lead him to capture international attention and leave an indelible mark on the classical music scene.

In 2018, Christian made waves in the classical music world when he became the youngest-ever winner of the prestigious Menuhin Competition. Held in Geneva, Switzerland, this competition is a crucible for the world’s most promising young violinists. Christian not only secured the joint Junior 1st Prize but also made history by play-conducting a movement of Vivaldi’s timeless masterpiece, “The Four Seasons,” alongside the Geneva Chamber Orchestra. This remarkable achievement marked the beginning of Christian Li’s ascent to stardom.

During his time at the Menuhin Competition, Christian Li’s talent shone brightly, earning him not just the Junior 1st Prize but also the Audience Prize and the Composer Award. These accolades showcased not only his virtuosity but also his ability to connect with audiences on a profound level and his deep understanding of the nuances of classical compositions.

In 2020, Christian reached another milestone by becoming the youngest artist to sign with Decca Classics, a renowned record label in the classical music industry. His debut album, released in August 2021, featured Vivaldi’s “The Four Seasons” alongside other exquisite works for violin and piano by composers like Bazzini, Kreisler, Massenet, and Li Zilli. The album received widespread acclaim, earning five-star reviews from critics and audiences alike. BBC Music Magazine praised his performance, noting that he brought “thrilling virtuosity and myriad colors to Vivaldi’s fast movements” and delivered an “exquisitely silky cantabile sound to the aria-like slow movements.”

Christian Li’s prowess extends beyond the recording studio. He has graced the stages of prestigious orchestras and concert halls around the world. His acclaimed debuts include performances with the Sydney Symphony Orchestra, Melbourne Symphony Orchestra, the Australian Brandenburg Orchestra, Auckland Philharmonia, Oslo Philharmonic, and Gavle Symphony. Moreover, he has showcased his talent in recitals in Israel, Norway, and the UK, solidifying his reputation as a violinist of remarkable skill and versatility.

Currently, Christian holds the prestigious position of Young Artist in Association with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra for a three-year period. During this tenure, he will perform a diverse range of concertos, chamber music, and recitals, enriching the Australian classical music scene.

In the 2023/24 season, Christian Li is set to return to the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra twice, first in September 2023 to perform Mozart’s Violin Concerto No. 3 and then in July 2024 with Paganini’s Violin Concerto No. 1. He is also making orchestral debuts with the RTV Slovenian Radio Symphony, Aalborg Symphony, the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic, and the Macao Orchestra, where he will perform Tchaikovsky’s mesmerizing Violin Concerto. Additionally, he will make a triumphant return to the Oslo Philharmonic Orchestra, this time playing and directing Vivaldi’s “The Four Seasons.” Christian’s talents extend to recitals as well, as he is scheduled to perform in Taipei and Kaoshiung, Taiwan, alongside pianist Nicola Eimer and at the Vancouver Recital Society with Rohan de Silva.

Christian Li’s musical journey is enriched by the use of the 1737 ex-Paulsen Guarneri del Gesù violin, generously loaned to him by a benefactor. His bow, crafted by François Peccatte, complements his exquisite instrument, allowing him to produce the enchanting and mesmerizing sounds that have captivated audiences worldwide.

While Christian’s dedication to music is unwavering, he also enjoys a well-rounded life outside of the concert stage. He currently studies with Dr. Robin Wilson at the Yehudi Menuhin School in London, where he hones his skills with a mentor who recognizes his immense potential. In his free time, Christian enjoys reading, swimming, and bike riding, illustrating that even prodigies have a balance between their artistic pursuits and personal interests.

In the world of classical music, Christian Li stands as a shining example of exceptional talent, dedication, and boundless potential. With each performance, he leaves an indelible mark on the hearts and minds of those fortunate enough to witness his musical brilliance. As he continues to evolve and mature as an artist, the world eagerly awaits the next chapters in Christian Li’s remarkable musical journey.

Hochschule für Musik Hannover

Hochschule für Musik Hannover

Excellence at the highest level

Top Classical, January 2023
The Hanover University of Music, Drama and Media Hannover (HMTMH) is one of Germany´s most renowned institutions for professional training and academic study in the cultural and artistic field. Some 360 teachers, amongst them numerous internationally celebrated artists, educationalists and academics, teach nearly 1,500 students from all over the world.

HMTMH traces its history back to the “Landesmusikschule” (State music school) and the “Hannoversche Schauspielschule” (Hannover Drama School), both of which were founded as early as the 19th century. They then formed the “Akademie für Musik und Theater” (Academy of Music and Theatre) in 1950; in 1973, the Federal State of Lower Saxony became responsible for managing the University.It was in 1958 when the school achieved the status of Hochschule. Since 2001 the university runs an institute for the early training of highly gifted students, the ‘Institut zur Früh-Förderung Hochbegabter’ (IFF, Institute for the Advancement of Young Musicians).

In 2010, it added the term “media” to its name. Today, its institutes are located in various places around the city – from the east side of Hanover to the Expo Plaza.

Eleven institutes serve to bring students and scholars together, creating impetus and acting as a catalyst for unique research. The disciplines of Acting and Media Management complement HMTMH’s outstanding reputation as a music academy, making it Germany’s third-largest art university.

The balance between music, drama, education and academic research, and the commitment to excellence at the highest level of performance and in broader training form the core of HMTMH’s understanding of its role. To this end, HMTHM provides a differentiated offering of degree programs, supplemented by numerous master classes. Music plays the key role. Thanks to many cross-discipline art research projects, almost all fields can be approached in an interdisciplinary manner.

The drama and opera departments are in close cooperation with the Staatsoper Hannover, the Staatstheater Hannover and the NDR Radiophilharmonie. About 500 public concerts and performances a year make the HMTMH one of the biggest organizers of cultural events in the State of Lower Saxony. In order to provide long-term support for “Hanover, Region of Culture” and “Lower Saxony, Land of Music”, Lower Saxony’s only conservatoire stays in a permanent exchange with society and initiates a number of musical outreach activities.

Notable artists such as Igor Levit, Yundi Li, Lars Vogt or Sabine Meyer are only some of the names who studied there in the past.

Further information about the university and their academic programs can be found on HMTMH webpage: https://www.hmtm-hannover.de/en/home/ 

Fairy Tales

Fairy Tales

Enchanting Whispers: Fairy Tales – Regula Mühlemann’s Arias and Songs

December 2022
Regula Mühlemann, a soprano of remarkable talent, invites listeners to a world of enchantment and fantasy with her latest release, “Fairy Tales.” Delving into a collection of arias and songs by diverse composers such as Adam, Britten, Dvořák, Grieg, Massenet, Mendelssohn, Monteverdi, Offenbach, Purcell, and Verdi, Mühlemann showcases her prowess as a storyteller through music. Joined by the CHAARTS Chamber Artists under the direction of Wolfgang Renz, this album takes us on a journey through the realm of fairy tales, both familiar and obscure.

The album’s theme of fairy tales is captivating, as it showcases a medley of characters and narratives, each reflecting a different facet of the magical world. From the ethereal Rusalka in Dvořák’s eponymous opera to the endearing La Fée in Massenet’s Cendrillon, Mühlemann’s vocal versatility shines as she brings these characters to life. While the inclusion of Solveig’s aria from Grieg’s “Peer Gynt” might raise an eyebrow, it nevertheless adds a unique dimension to the compilation, leaving us pondering the intricate connection between literature and music.

One intriguing aspect of “Fairy Tales” is the inclusion of purely orchestral movements from Grieg’s incidental music, contributing an instrumental interlude that beautifully weaves together the thematic essence of the album. While some might question the cohesion of such an approach, it adds an element of diversity and depth to the listening experience, underscoring the ethereal nature of the fairy tale world.

Mühlemann’s vocal artistry is showcased wonderfully in this album, her performances capturing the nuances of each character and narrative. Her rendition of the Cendrillon aria exhibits her ethereal tone and mastery of coloratura, painting a vivid picture of the fairy tale princess. Equally captivating is her interpretation of Mendelssohn’s ‘Neue Liebe,’ which carries a delicate undertone of menace, creating an enticingly mysterious atmosphere. Throughout the album, Mühlemann’s vocal control and emotive delivery draw us into the enchanting tales.

However, some listeners might find themselves wishing for a more substantial orchestral accompaniment to complement Mühlemann’s vocals. The decision to utilize the CHAARTS Chamber Artists, though executed well by Wolfgang Renz, occasionally leaves a yearning for a richer orchestral texture that could have enhanced the magical ambiance even further.

“Fairy Tales” boasts moments of true enchantment, particularly in the selections that align seamlessly with Mühlemann’s strengths. The Barcarolle from Offenbach’s “Die Rheinnixen” and Nannetta’s aria from Verdi’s “Falstaff” hold their own as engaging performances, yet they do not quite reach the same level of exceptional artistry found in other tracks.

In sum, “Fairy Tales” is a captivating journey into the realm of imagination and wonder, where Regula Mühlemann’s captivating vocals and the artistry of CHAARTS Chamber Artists intertwine to bring classic characters and stories to life. With its blend of ethereal enchantment and moments of vocal brilliance, this album is an invitation to escape into the spellbinding world of fairy tales, where music and storytelling converge in harmonious magic.

Schwanengesang

Schwanengesang

Schwanengesang – A Soulful Exploration of Schubert’s Final Songs with Andrè Schuen and Daniel Heide

December 2022
Schwanengesang, a collection of Franz Schubert’s last 14 songs, finds its perfect interpreters in the exceptional baritone Andrè Schuen and the accomplished pianist Daniel Heide. This is Schuen’s second Schubert album in a row, following his reading of the Die schöne Müllerin cycle, and it is evident that he is rapidly establishing himself as a Schubert specialist.

The album opens with ‘Liebesbotschaft,’ where Schuen’s voice beautifully captures the bubbling brook and the emotions of a young man who once fell in love with the Miller’s daughter. Moving on, the mood takes a darker turn in ‘Kriegers Ahnung,’ with Schuen’s introspective rendition and Heide’s piano subtly adding depth to the last verse, leaving a poignant piano note lingering in the air.

One of the strengths of this album lies in its freer structure, as Schwanengesang was posthumously assembled by a publisher, allowing Schuen’s voice to shine and fully express the pure beauty of his singing. It is evident that Schuen drew inspiration from listening to Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau’s recording of this cycle during his youth. While he may not have Fischer-Dieskau’s gift for unexpected psychological insights, Schuen’s performance in the lengthy and sparse ‘Der Doppelgänger’ is impressive, showcasing his vocal control and emotional intensity. Even in familiar melodies like ‘Ständchen,’ Schuen successfully injects expressive spaces that resonate with the listener.

The collaboration between Andrè Schuen and Daniel Heide is nothing short of remarkable, and their partnership seems endlessly productive, akin to the legendary pairing of Fischer-Dieskau with Gerald Moore. Heide’s sensitive and skillful accompaniment perfectly complements Schuen’s vocal artistry, creating a captivating musical experience.

As the album progresses into the Heine settings, Schubert’s protean approach to songwriting comes to the fore. From straightforwardly strophic styles reminiscent of Beethoven to through-composed pieces hinting at the future of German lieder, Schubert’s versatility is masterfully brought to life by Schuen and Heide.

A notable highlight is the haunting ‘Der Doppelgänger,’ where Schuen’s empathetic interpretation evokes deep emotional anxiety as the poet/singer confronts his own reflection. The chilling sequence of slow-moving chords in the piano further intensifies the sense of unease and introspection.

Andrè Schuen and Daniel Heide’s rendition of Schwanengesang is a deeply moving and captivating musical journey. Schuen’s distinct vocal charm and Heide’s brilliant accompaniment paint a vivid picture of Schubert’s final songs, touching upon themes of lost love and introspection. While paying homage to the great interpretations of the past, these young artists bring their unique sensibilities to the music, promising an exciting future for Schubert’s lieder repertoire. This album is an exceptional offering from Andrè Schuen, a singer who is undoubtedly one to watch in the world of classical music.

BBC Cardiff Singer of the World

BBC Cardiff Singer of the World

The ineludible meeting for the best world singers

Top Classical, December 2022
Held every two years, this prestigious competition for singers from around the world was launched to celebrate the hall’s opening in 1983. 

 It was founded by BBC Cymru Wales, and it is opened to singers at the start of their professional careers, aged 18-32.  Starting from 18 singers in the first year, each nominated by their local broadcasting organisation, the number of contestants keep growing year by year. Competing on the very first evening was the now legendary Finnish soprano Karita Mattila, who went on to win the competition.  

In the last editions more than 300 talented singers from 55 countries applied to come to the capital of Wales to represent their country. Contestants are auditioned by the Competition staff to select the final 20.  The last BBC Cardiff Singer of the World competition in 2019 featured 20 singers from 15 countries, and for the first time the line-up included a singer from Guatemala. The 20 singers competed for the Main Prize, Song Prize and Audience Prize, the latter of which was dedicated to the memory of baritone Dmitri Hvorostovsky, who died in 2017 and won the competition in 1989. 

The contestants need to excel in a wide range of singing skills. The event is adjudicated by a panel of distinguished international jurors and the constants need to perform opera and concert music with full orchestra in four concerts. The winner from each concert plus one wild card (the best of the rest) competes in the final. This takes place in St David’s Hall, Cardiff. 

St David’s Hall, Cardiff

The reason of its popularity can be found in the the £15,000 prize money and possibly a BBC engagement. In addition, an engagement with Welsh National Opera may also be offered. The four other finalists receive £2,500 each.  

In addition, the competition in liaison with BBC Radio 3 will commission a new piece from composer John Lunn. It will be written especially for the winner, who will give its first performance at the 2016 BBC Proms, with the BBC National Orchestra of Wales. 

The winner of the BBC Cardiff Singer of the World Song Prize receives £5,000 and the Song Prize Trophy. 

Baritone Gihoon Kim, from Republic of Korea was the winner of the latest edition of the BBC Cardiff Singer of the World. He had studied singing at Yonsei University in Seoul before he received a scholarship at the Junge Oper Hannover, where he sang roles including Demetrius (A Midsummer Night’s Dream) and Marullo (Rigoletto).
“It has been an inspiring journey – and one that I will definitely remember for the rest of my career,” he said of the victory.

We can’t wait to meet the fierce contestants who will be ready to compete in the upcoming competition, which will take place next year, in 2023. If you are looking for the most promising classical music voices and the future star singers, keep a close eye on this outstanding competition!

Schumann Symphonies Nos. 1-4

Schumann Symphonies Nos. 1-4

Schumann Symphonies Nos. 1-4 – A Traditional Perspective with Barenboim’s Masterful Long Lines

December 2022
When it comes to interpreting the works of a complex composer like Robert Schumann, various perspectives can illuminate different facets of his music. In this notable release from Deutsche Grammophon, maestro Daniel Barenboim and the Staatskapelle Berlin present Schumann’s Symphonies Nos. 1-4 with a more traditional approach, inviting listeners to immerse themselves in the rich orchestral textures and indulgent pacing that this interpretation offers.

Alfred Brendel’s observation that great music transcends any specific performance finds resonance in this recording. While the lean and quirky interpretation of Schumann’s symphonies, as championed by John Eliot Gardiner’s iconic DG set, has brought new dimensions to the composer’s repertoire, Barenboim’s rendition stands as a counterpoint—a Schumann that is magisterial, embracing unhurried tempos and a sense of unhindered expression.

Barenboim’s ability to craft a compelling long line in his interpretations shines brilliantly throughout this recording. His skillful phrasing creates a sense of continuous, unbroken melody, akin to experiencing a Wagnerian music-drama as one sustained lyrical journey. Moments such as the languid slow movement of the Second Symphony and the grandiose ‘cathedral’ fourth movement of the ‘Rhenish’ Symphony are imbued with a profound emotional depth, stirring both conviction and sentimentality.

The warmth and depth of the orchestral sound presented in this rendition may initially surprise those accustomed to the more modern, revisionist interpretations of Schumann’s symphonies. However, with time, the listener becomes attuned to the indulgence in sonic richness that Barenboim and the Staatskapelle Berlin deliver. The horns and flute ‘awakening’ in the finale of the ‘Spring’ Symphony, for instance, are treated with loving attention, inviting us to appreciate these fleeting moments of beauty.

Yet, in this departure from the edgy, quick-witted Schumann unveiled by Gardiner’s interpretation, certain aspects do recede. The internal struggle within the Second Symphony, which Gardiner masterfully illuminated, takes on a softer hue here, trading intensity for a more lush resonance. Similarly, the Fourth Symphony, historically known for its ability to confound and challenge audiences, emerges from Barenboim’s baton with a sense of grandiosity and confidence that some may find more assertive than introspective.

In a world where Schumann’s symphonies can be dissected and presented through a variety of lenses, Barenboim’s recording stands as a tribute to the enduring power of tradition. While some of the intricate and provocative elements of Schumann’s compositions may be smoothed over in this rendition, what remains is an unabashed celebration of orchestral beauty and melodic lyricism. For those seeking a different angle on these masterworks, Barenboim’s take provides a sumptuous and emotive journey that reminds us that even amidst evolving interpretations, the heart of Schumann’s music still beats with timeless vigor.