Brahms by Pavel Haas

June 2022
The Pavel Haas Quartet and Boris Giltburg present a fearless and captivating rendition of Brahms’ monumental Piano Quintet in F minor. This work, which went through various iterations before settling into its current form, finds new life in the hands of these talented musicians. The performance is characterized by an unyielding commitment to the music, resulting in an overall thrilling experience, though at times, it may border on excessive.

The strength of this recording lies in the quartet’s unwavering sense of involvement and their unreserved emotional investment. The musicians showcase their innate ensemble playing and demonstrate a strong instinct for tempo, leading to a dynamic and energetic performance that leaves little room for respite, except in the beautifully tranquil second movement. The musicians seem to be giving it their all, pushing the boundaries and capturing the listeners’ attention from start to finish.

However, the all-giving approach has its drawbacks, particularly in the first movement, where the intensity occasionally veers towards heaviness. Moreover, in the outer movements, the aggressive string sounds tend to dominate for extended periods, potentially overwhelming listeners, especially when using headphones. While this approach may work well in a large concert hall, it can become less suitable for intimate listening environments.

On a more positive note, the recording also features Brahms’ later String Quintet, a gentler and more genial piece. Here, the musicians strike a better balance, maintaining the thrilling qualities while avoiding excessive forcefulness. The ensemble playing remains remarkable, showcasing a deep appreciation and affection for the music.

Sonically, the recording boasts strong and bright sound quality, which complements the ensemble’s energetic approach. However, this may contribute to the slightly in-your-face aspect of the performance, reinforcing the dominance of the aggressive string sounds in certain movements.

In summary, Pavel Haas Quartet and Boris Giltburg deliver an engaging and intense rendition of Brahms’ Piano Quintet, brimming with passion and musicality. Their innate ensemble playing and instinct for tempo shine throughout the recording. However, the heightened intensity might not be for everyone, especially in certain movements where a lighter touch could enhance the overall experience. Nonetheless, the thrilling qualities of the performance, combined with the gentler charm of the String Quintet, make this CD a compelling addition to the Brahms repertoire.